Rainforest

mosquitoAfter watching Merlin Mann’s recent video on make-believe help I started thinking about the relationships, in particular on the internet, that are being used for survival. Merlin’s video was response to a satirical video he made yesterday about the sometimes ridiculous hacks that self-help type sites put up. For me the 30 odd minutes he uses to explain his point came down to two things

  • stated clearly – think about who is telling you how to be you
  • less clearly –  much of internet business is based on keeping people reliant on receiving information on who  to be/what to do

Merlin is particularly nice about how he describes this industry. He doesn’t condemn it outright, but it is clear that it troubles him, and troubles him a lot.

I can see where he is going, and I agree with his sentiment. Yet the conundrum that Merlin finds himself in (and me too) is there is no black and white answer for each of the world’s ills, no matter how much we want to say “this is the cure”. There is no magic bullet.The example of the butcher with 40 years experience is quite true, there is no substitute for actually doing the work.

Does that mean that helping people on the internet is a bad thing? The answer is no and yes.

Humans, business and the internet are like a rainforest to me. You have the predators that make their own way in life (entrepreneurs) who are out there killing and eating (and dying). Then you have the symbiotic relationships where one entity is supported by another, and gives back in their own way  (employees, networks) and finally the parasites who live off of the others but do not kill them as that would end their meal ticket (service industries such as self help).

Parasite has a negative connotation because it is seen as less of an effort to sup from the rest of the rainforest, than to go out and create your own mini system where you are top of the food chain. There is work involved in being a parasite though; sourcing your sustenance, getting to it, keeping it close by. In service industries this can be “creating a clientèle” , a fan base, your tribe. There is a niche and you fit right in there doing what you do.

In a perfect world one stop solutions would be available for every ill you will come up against; one haircut lasting for life, one inoculation for all diseases, one way to get motivated. There isn’t and there can’t be, so what is the next best thing? Offering the cure where there is a cure, and making sure the person purchasing your services are pre-qualified to ensure they take the cure.

This goes against what most of the continuity based programs out there in the “make money online” land. You must find the mark, hit them up for a program, ensure they stick around for as long as possible. You are the mosquito and if you take small enough sips the cash cow is never going to notice you are there (yes there are teachings that actually state how to do that). Or you find the mark, sell them a program, that leads up to selling another program, ad infinitum. The worst in the industry sell nothing but steps to get to the next program, not steps to get to the next level of expertise (which of course comes from experience and practice and no course).

Over at the SWBN we have struggled with how we can morally provide the best of services without being (or becoming) parasites ourselves. We could blame our clients not progressing on “human nature” and take their cash because they are stupid enough to give it to us, God knows the majority of programs out there do that and no wonder they are shit scared of the FTC ruling that says tell us how it really is. In the end we decided to take our coaching to a micro level. One person, one task, one focus. A “never want to see you here again with this problem” cure, that is financially less rewarding, but morally infinitely more so. I can hear the scoffing right now about “cash left on the table”, a term I have always despised, you can be grateful and happy with what you have, or you can bemoan what you left behind.

I know we will be happier being a cure, than being part of the problem.

Selling On The Internet – You Are Doing It Wrong

Several pieces of information have intersected and fell in place with an audible “click” for me this past fortnight as I launched the Secret Women’s Business Network blog.

One hint came from the tiny tome The Contrarian Effect (Why It Pays Big to Take Typical Sales Advice and Do The Opposite) by Michael Port and Elizabeth Marshall. Michael made the point that sales tactics and processes of yesteryear, while they may “appear” to work, they are short sighted, burn potential and repeat customers, and were designed with the seller in mind not the buyer.

How many of the large internet marketing launches did you feel was really to help you the customer compared to “I know this is all just trying to get as much money as quickly as possible”? The big boys in the business sniff at anyone saying that the current method of launching does not speak to them on a personal level. The big guys are missing the point entirely and should be careful they don’t lag behind.

If you are hearing feedback that your most savvy customers are not enjoying something on a personal level, you better listen. You are doing something wrong. You may gain short term customers, but you will lose those customers that are going to be most valuable to you, the long term, socially connected ones that will sell FOR you. With all the buzz currently about Seth Godin’s Tribes, I hope this message gets through, build your tribe, on a PERSONAL level. Be yourself and lead people like yourself.

The next piece of information came from a quick scan of this report (well it is 43 pages and I am out of printer paper!) that looked at 1000 socially connected consumers ( a massive group and getting larger every day). An absolute MUST read I believe.

The first tip in the social networking part of the report is to “Share the Spotlight”. Alas many of today’s marketers only share that spotlight with their product, or within their own network. It is not hard to see who masterminds with who (or who paid to be in a mastermind group with who) because that is ALL these people promote. They do not favourite the little people that “may” be a customer one day, they do not respond to random reachouts by social network users who are keen to speak to them. they have a closed loop happening and it is obvious to those outside of it.

The third part came from a Frank Kern give-away video that talked about the “Core Influence”. The same stuff I learned a few years ago while going through my NLP training, but when Frank delievers it to his audience it is a new concept to them because they are all still thinking of their customers as walking wallets. Frank takes them through the exercise of visualising their customers as a human being with a real life so they can connect better with that “person”.

Why is that such a radical idea? Why has connected with your customer on a “personal” level been the very last thing a sales person has wanted to do. Is it because they do not really believe in the tactics they are using and product they are selling? I certainly think so!

The new world demands authenticity. If there is even a hint of some form of duplicity your customers are going to find someone else to buy from, and there are a LOT of other sellers they are now aware of. Gone are the days of the single sales area of the Fuller Brush man; the internet means your customers can buy anywhere, any time, and they want that to be a friendly, fun purchase. They also want to buy from someone they LIKE, because the new consumer is VERY AWARE of where cash goes and what it does. Everyone prefers to help friends over strangers.

The oldest sales tactic of all, also has to go. I believe the “sales letter’, that wall of text that the seller convinces themselves works, is in it’s twilight. Why? Very soon the written word will not be “personal” enough on the internet unless it can be seen to have come spontaneously through social networking. This new measure of how we weight personal communication is already in place in the spoken word. A discussion amongst friends at the pub holds more weight with you than something you read in a magazine, even if it was written by an “expert”. The human algorithm says give more weight to the word of a friend over the word of a stranger (unless your friend is an idiot). It’s automatic!

I am watching with interest and curiously at the changes that are happening as the so-called sales gurus of the internet are evolving (and remember the whole internet marketing thing as an entity to itself is only about a decade old). As it dawns that there are better ways to do things, that the friendly shop keeper on the corner had it right, and the relationship between him and his customers was mutually respectful and long term, rather than the soul-less mall wham-bam of cash grabbing.

She Cannae Take It Any More

No she can’t. The crap that has filled my inbox for years has now been sorted. Irritating useless and blathering on internet marketers sending out the same hysterically (not funny, the screaming hysterics) worded crap about their amazing products, their system, their friend who has a product launching, their free offer that will magically escalate to paying for a $5k seminar.

This has been building up for a while. My distaste of pandering to the lowest common denominator of intelligence growing on a daily basis fed by crap journalism and constant contact with smart cynical people online.

Take last week’s furore in Australia over whether an artist’s pictures of a nude 15 year old girl was art or filthy child pornography. Sure it might not be my cup of tea for the lounge room wall but the baying hounds of the press were dead-set on ignoring the fact that intent has a lot to do with what art/pornography is. After a week on the front page being pilloried , the story that censors had deemed the image as “mild” and fully exonerated the artist was carried…in the entertainment section.

That’s why I choose to not read papers on a regular or daily basis, nor watch television.

Back to my brimming inbox that contained emails from about half a dozen to a dozen internet mailing lists. I performed a complete subscribectomy and thought about what I was getting from each one….and NOT ONE was worth my time. Not one was giving me anything but offer,offer,offer. Not one was checking on my welfare or caring about me as a customer or potential customer. The only thing these people wanted me for was to give them money. That was their only intent.

I have a mailing list in a niche. One that I started as a test, one that is sadly neglected. But every word that I have written for the auto-repsonder to send out is sincere and caring, and has no other intent then to help the people who have signed up. There is no product at the end of the newsletter series, there are no “great offers”. Which is why I regularly get emails from people asking me questions and asking for advice. Some are quite heartbreaking.

So why aren’t internet marketing email lists like that? Just great advice and no intent to sell? I would be more inclined to buy what they had if they were genuinely caring about what I want and who I am.

You Are NOT Your Khakis (Or Your Own Customer)

There is something mischievously satisfying about mixing a Fight Club quote about consumerism with a statement about your own market. Now I have finished congratulating myself on how clever I am, let’s consider what the implications are about not being your own customer.

I hate sales letters, absolutely, with a passion, abhor them. It is a constant surprise to me that they work. Why would anyone get sucked in to parting with cash by a wall of text in a bad font? Because I am not the average user of the internet.

This also goes for Facebook, I used to truly love it. Clean open spaces, Google-like in the pristine landscape of the monitor, like fresh snow untrodden. Then came the march of the applications, the millions of pokes and requests and demands for my time that I just DO NOT WANT

Keeping in mind that I am not my customer, I asked my sister a few questions about her Facebook usage. I would class her a complete n00b when it comes to the internet, PCs or anything remotely geeky. She has 2 children, is studying to become a Steiner teacher and works a couple of part-time jobs to pay the bills. She discovered Facebook about 8 months ago and has been using it ever since. I asked her 10 questions about her usage (via Facebook naturally) and asked her to respond.

1. how often do you use Facebook a day
3 – 4 times

2. Do you have a favourite application
Yes…chat

3. Do all the application requests affect you in any way
Yes…get tedious after a while. Sick of same shit from new people.

4 . Does Facebook help you in any way
Yes…expand my social circle, locate old friends/classmates, find love, keep in touch with friends and family.

5. Do you notice the ads in facebook?
I notice ads but not sure if I notice them all.

6. what do you dislike about facebook
Forced requests, poor spelling….everywhere!

7. do you use any other social networking sites on the internet (like myspace or twitter etc)
No

8. Do you like Facebook any more or less since you started using it
Like it more

9. How would you rate your PC and internet expertise
Out of 10?….5. (AR: pfft she is SO a 2, maybe a 3)

10. How would you improve Facebook if you could
Easier control over News Feed items.

Ok so she puts up with the application requests, even though they clearly irritate her, she uses it as a tool for social contact (as it is designed to be used), and she likes it more now then when she started. Contrast that to me who stopped using it regularly because the social contact I got was not satisfying, the application requests were annoying, and the barrage of groups demanding time and attention for dire social issues, and crappy marketing efforts used up my sympathy quota very quickly. Yep we are definitely not alike in our opinion of Facebook!

So this week when Stompernet opened its doors and Ed Dale video responded to the Open Letter To Stompernet I was thinking along different lines. I have always applied the “quality product” tag to Stompernet due to what I have heard from people who run Stompernet. To me this is a premium learning experience that is expensive but also valuable, like a good certification or university course. I also thought it was not for beginners.

Yet the launch of the open door seemed….aimed at a lower common denominator than I though the market would be. The lead up had been great, the free content awesome but the same old, same old on opening day was a let down. This confused me, these guys are marketing geniuses and yet they are pitching way lower than their product deserves. Aren’t they going for people like me that kind of sorta understands some stuff and wants to take the next step up?

Then it hit me, I am not their customer (even though I thought I might have been) , just like I am not my own.

Kind of like quantum physics, my observation of something will affect the outcome. In this case my “marketing” brain and my “customer” brain collided. I had expectations that I was going to get X but I got Y. A valuable lesson for me, and one I will keep with me as I go forward.

I am not my customer, I am not my customer…..

On Being A Window Washer

One particularly unpleasant online marketer (sorry can’t remember his name or his site as he was poisonous), one of those types that is constantly negative about other people, used the term window washer (or window cleaner) to describe someone who was looking in at the successful people and trying to emulate what they did, or stealing their ideas.

Now the term might be very common in IM circles, or just this guy’s little joke, but at the time it hit a chord with me.

I don’t know where I am in the scheme of things. I am not as successful as I would like to be (yet) and I seem to be pedaling but not in gear. I am watching and learning and in some things I think I am going pretty well, in others I fear I am considered a window washer.

Why is it there are probably 5 or more successful male IMs to each female? Is it because we don’t have that male self possession that drives you through these very doubts. Maybe.

I really need a mentor that I can bounce this stuff off….